I am as sceptical of Diane's analysis as I was of the late Maire Drumm's claim that the working class people of the Catholic Falls and the Protestants of the Shankill could settle the conflict over a pot of tea. Interestingly, I remember one republican-minded singer producing a comparable argument when appropriating the song for his own use some years ago. Diane is as entitled to think of it as a "ridiculous simplification" as I am to thank Tommy Sands for telling a tragic story, with whatever licence had to be applied to the details of the two deaths, in such a powerfully moving way. And to Cara for her outstanding interpretation. The remainder of my interview with Cara - just a very short Q&A with a couple of clips, one Cara/Sam/Paul Brady and the other Cara's sister Mary - has now been posted at Salut! Live
|