Well, it seemed to me that the message that was getting through was

"RA thinks SO'P is a rubbish musician",

when what RA had actually said was

"RA thinks SO'P sometimes talks rubbish on Mudcat"

That's not a nice thing to have said about you, I don't endorse it and I don't blame Suibhne for taking offence. But I just wanted to make the point that there's a difference between being criticised as a Mudcat poster and being criticised as a musician - that is, one is much, much, much, much less serious than the other. (Example: me. I wouldn't be writing like this if you'd criticised my singing, let me tell you.)