I don't understand your reasoning, Megan. Salmond, by the way, is only spearheading the referendum, there are many people, including myself, who are not members of the SNP who would like to see Scotlamd handling it's own affairs. All this talk of the referendum being identity driven is garbage. I am Scottish but live in England so I don't have a it. An Englishman, or anyone of a non Scottish identity who lives in Scotland can vote which is entirely correct. Caroline Leckie makes a great case for a bright future for all who live in Scotland. Smile, don't frown.