Whatever the case, if you're requesting a song, it's expected that you post what you already know, so people look for the right song, and to give people a head start if they have to transcribe the song.
Reinhard has posted far more than his fair share of songs, and some of our most prolific lyrics-posters get feeling that people take advantage of their generosity. I've never known Reinhard to be rude or sarcastic.
It does get frustrating when a requester furnishes nothing about a song but the title and the recording artist. Those who request without giving, are the ones more likely to be rude. I checked the version in the Digital Tradition (see link above), and it seems to be an accurate transcription.
-Joe Offer, Music Editor-

---

Wikipedia article on Allister MacGillivray