Sorry Keith, I have never even attempted to disprove what you say. I do not know who you mean by 'you people' but it is phrases like that, coupled with 'over a year of frantic googling', that you cannot possibly prove either, that make a nonsense of any intelligent argument. Failing to find proof to the contrary is NOT proof of fact. Your fact is nothing but a theory and you cannot say that all living historians support your position until you have read the work of all living historians. Until you are in that position please stop saying that all living historians support you. Even the rider that all living historians WHO'S WORK YOU HAVE READ would be an improvement.