I started discussions on this topic on a couple of other traditional music websites after noticing an article in Thursday's "Times". There was a large gathering of traditional flute players in Edinburgh this past weekend, and a few of us went down to have a look at the flute.
As it is, it is not in any way playable. Neither Niall Kenny, nor I could get a note out of it, as it has long cracks down 2 sides of the headjoint. The middle sections are in better condition, the single key which should be on the foot-joint is absent.
I'm no expert on "Bonny" Prince Charlie, but as this was the first time I'd ever heard it suggested that he was a flute player, I was fairly skeptical, and the "provenance" of the instrument listed by the auctioneers didn't seem all that convincing to me. I should say that the staff at Lyon & Turnbull were exceedingly friendly, and allowed us to have a good look at the flute, take some photographs, and even try playing it. If Jack should manage along - and I think the auction items are on display today, as well as tomorrow before the actual auction, he should find them very helpful.
I also spoke on the phone to Mr. Colin Fraser of Lyon & Turnbull yesterday morning, and he is of the opinion that the provenance
is strong.
I hope Jack can get along for a look, and would be interested to hear his opinions.
I won't be bidding !
Kenny