Many thanks indeed for your kind response to my enquiry. I had spent some time doing MacColl searches and they directed me to a book"Personal Choice" which was published in the late fifties and to which I had access for a short while during the sixties. However for all his massive recorded output there is reletivley little around these days on CD. The versions posted by Malcolm Douglas and yrlancslad are invaluable; if ever you visit Traditions at the Tiger, Long Eaton, Notts., I`ll buy you a pint. Honest.