Sandy, I agree with you with regard to the timing of the music. The standardization that I am referring to has to do with basic technique only. As the popularity of the instrument grows, the "mystical" aspects of setting them up, tuning them for a gig, and the basic use of rolls, cuts, crans, and other ornaments and graces need to be formalized in order that it isn't so damn hard to find the information and get tuition. Remember that, until fairly recently, this was an instrument designed for solo playing. It's tuning was only relative to itself. Now that it is being played in ensembles, the need to standardise certain aspects of its construction and playing. HOWEVER, that does not mean I am in favor of standardization of the correct way to play any style of the music. One of the things that created our greatest UP'ers (such as Clancy, Rowsomme, and on and on)was the habit of playing on their own and interpreting as they felt. I agree completely with you that I would not want to see any standardization of "the right way to play a tune".

You mentioned the old "Gaelic" style of playing the warpipes. Can you direct me to any resources on this? I am purchasing a Great Highland practice chanter, and eventually want to add a set of Irish Warpipes to my collection. I am very interested in learning this instrument in the Gaelic style.

All the best,

Mick