The fiddle, which is a staple of what we consider TRADITIONAL Irish music, really did not come into use until the 18th century in Ireland, and even then it was used by more wealthy musicians - not the average family. As Martin points out, singers have their own feelings about instruments.   I've heard stories about Joe Heaney, the incredible sean nos singer, who supposedly had a very descriptive opinion about guitars when they were brought into sessions.

The point is, traditional music CHANGES. While we will never agree on a definition of folk music, I do feel that locale, circumstance and availability effect the music. That is why we have dozens of variations of the same song - each specific to a time and place. The music was played on whatever instrument happened to be available - the instrument of a solo voice, a harp, a drum, etc.

This doesn't mean we have to personally embrace these sounds, but it should mean that we can understand the changes without dismissing them. I certainly don't like everything I hear. There are many musicians whose music irritates me for various reasons, but I always respect their RIGHT to experiment and find the sound that is heard in THEIR soul.   I can still appreciate what they are doing AND keep my deep love for traditional music.

Ron