I agree with the sentiments re. Moira; a sweet [trained] singer, but like others of her ilk, tends to "take the soul" out of Scottish folk songs. [ Ken McKellar was exactly the same till he suddenly "got wise" after doing a mini-telly-series with Jean Redpath and Alastair MacDonald] Nice seeing a discussion of "Rothesay Bay". A very dear old Pal died a few years back, and left me his accordion. I make it a duty every New Years night to be at his club to play his favourite tune on the squeezebox--Rothesay Bay.