Some not mentioned:
Streets of London
Rollin' in My Sweet Baby's Arms
City of New Orleans
Thanksgiving Eve
Circle Game
Werewolves of London (yeah, it's a rock song, but everyone in the audience loves to go "Ah-WOO!" whenever I play it)
The Last Thing On My Mind
Will The Circle Be Unbroken
The Boxer
The Weight
and, of course, The Dutchman

Not to get morbid or weepy here, but the first time I ever heard Streets of London was when Fred Holstein did it live at the Barbarossa in 1979.