The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #67753   Message #1135683
Posted By: McGrath of Harlow
13-Mar-04 - 03:54 PM
Thread Name: BS: Costa Terror
Subject: RE: BS: Costa Terror
Prior to the Iraq invasion there was a training camp in minority Iraq which, according to some reports, was used by al Qaida.

This was in a part of Iraq which was outside the control of Baghdad, because it was in between the Kurdish enclave and the Iranian border. That meant Saddam couldn't get at them - with some justice he regarded Islamic fundamentalism as a deadly danger to his regime. Nor could the Iranians, where the Al Qaida version of Islam is also very much out of favour.

...........................

The reasons given in that link Amos gave for not regarding that claim by "the Abu Hafs Al-Masri Brigades" as being an authentic Al Qaida document don't seem to add up to much. They seem to be based on the assumption that "Al Qaida" means a centralised organisation with a fixed "house-style" when it comes to press releases and such. That seems a very problematic assumption indeed. It seems only too likely that what is involved is a very decentralised organisation, with cells and groups operating relatively autonomously, and involving people with a relatively wide range of backgrounds, reflected in these kinds of differences in terminology.