I'm not sure on that Villain. Some cases seem so clear that even the bowler knows when he appeals and bowlers at times can be a bit over-zealous in their appealing. I fear time wasting more than anything if 3rd umpire made every decision.

On the other hand I don't know how an umpire does his job. You could add someone maybe snicking a ball with the bat to your equation... And that could bring us on to catches...

Tell me one thing: Why do we have the different rules for in line, leg side, and off side for LBW.

Jon