Excellent! I have put in a request at the Library of Congress for a search for info on D'Arcy and a copyright date on Skelly--The literary sleuth in me makes me think that this is one of those "Quest for the Grail" type things, where there are a number of items by different authors from the same time period that seem to contain the same source material--which allude to an even older source--
Also, ASCAP credits the song to one Andrew Jenkins, published by Shapiro and Bernstein--no date listed, but I will call them--