Update for Gin (post of 6th) - point of info - sorry but neither of the Yorkshire clubs you mention (Skipton and Baccapipes in Keighley) qualify, purely cos they're not non-smoking. Sad to say, a large number of equally good clubs "oop north" are eliminated by virtue of allowing smoking within their club room/s. (OK I know this thread's not the place to air (sic!) views on smoking in clubs....)