BillD posted a warning in one of the Getaway threads that Debby McClatchey only puts out creamy peanut butter, much to the distress of us die-hard crunchy addicts. My husband insists that my Crunchy Jif isn't made correctly -it's supposed to be peanut "butter", smooth and creamy. To keep peace in our marriage and home, we have TWO jars of peanut butter open at all times (but it doesn't stop him from making the occasional disparaging comment about MY peanut butter, which actually has Peanuts in it!).

Is this a religious difference? How do other 'Catters resolve this kind of conflict? (Mayonnaise vs. Miracle Whip, French's vs. Grey Poupon, etc.) Can this marriage be saved?