Graham:

I had the same reaction to that quoted soldier as you did.

I knew I was making a Devil's breakfast when I made the comparison to hazing, but I still think it's valid while I do not hold it up as an excuse. I'm sure you are aware that hazing has also been physical and has led to death in cases. Hazing is also comparatively rare, because when it is overdone the authorities clamp down on it. I went to several American colleges and didn't run into it at all.

And I'm sure you agree with me that harm HAS been done, to the prisoners, to the vast majority of American soldiers who are doing a tough job for their country, and to the American image.