1. I don't mean anything. As I said, the quote was from a discussion on the Scots Music list and I make no warranties as to the accuracy of anything. I got it off the Digest so I don't know who posted what. I have never heard of this Irish song under either title. I suppose that one could alter it depending upon one's taste in roses:)

2. I no longer have the FAQ for either the Scots music list or the Cape Breton music list. Unfortunately unlike most lists the subscribe/unsubscribe information is not at the bottom of the posts. Try a Liszt search -- if you can't find the subscribe information e-mail me personally and I will seek the information from the listmaster.