I doubt Greg knows what "positive" means. Certainly, everyone can share their opinion, but it's pretty sad when blanket statements are pawned off as the truth.

Slamming everyone who has rewritten a song is a pretty sad activity.

There are many good rewritten songs out there. And frankly, many songs what were created from nothing suck pretty badly too. Even songs that we hold dear during the holiday season aren't exactly Shakespeare.

I would post some of my Yuletide songs here, but I decdied not to post my own work at Mudcat a couple years ago because of louts who will critique something to death merely for their own amusement.