I have a Lowden O25 (my second Lowden, had an O10 previously) and a Martin J-40. Both equally 'good', but in different ways. The Lowden's loud and woody, the Martin's quieter and very smooth. Would hate to part with either.

I reckon this kind of 'brand v. brand' batting back-and-forth is a pointless argument. Can't be won. We all have different eyes and ears, and our boats are floated in different ways. The individual has to spend time trying lots of instruments, then it's make your mind up and splash the cash time. IMHO.
S:0)