It's worth pointing out (what real folkies already know) that Martin Carthy was once a floor singer.

HE remembers that, which is why he is always willing to accept a fee much lower than his true worth, to appear in a small club which could not otherwise afford him. Also, unlike many more recent "stars", he has always sat through the floor spots (with evident enjoyment), rather than disappearing to the bar till his turn to play.

On at least three occasions, I have heard him approach a weak performer, and offer a few words of encouragement, and I was present when he spent ten minutes during the break showing a player how to play a particular piece.

That's why he is one of the best loved, and most respected artists in the country.

I wish there were many more like him, and fewer who sneer at performers, who are doing their (generally improving) best.

BTW not everyone has an eidetic memory. Some people try very hard, but still can't remember all the words. You wouldn't sneer at an orchestra for having the sheet music on stands in front of them, so why belittle a singer who uses song sheets? It isn't usually a case of "can't be a***d".

Don T.