The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #84514   Message #1560938
Posted By: kendall
11-Sep-05 - 07:17 AM
Thread Name: Lyr ADD: Make and Break Harbour (Stan Rogers)
Subject: RE: Lyr Req: Make and Break Harbour (Stan Rogers)
Having actually been to sea for many years (Stan was a land lubber) some of his lyrics just don't scan.
For instance, ..foreign trawlers go by with their long (all) seeing eye... refers to the electronic fish finders that are so efficient that nothing escapes them.

And, old used up nets are THROWN away what with being useless and all.

I consider Stan Rogers to be one of the all time great song writers, but I wish I had never met him. He was a bully and a crashing boor.The only Canadian I ever met whom I took an instant dislike to. Maybe he spent too much time in the states.

I read that biography; it's worth the reading. Maybe if I had gotten to know him I would have liked him, but that one weekend at Indian Neck was all I wanted of him.