The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #88402   Message #1661429
Posted By: Teribus
04-Feb-06 - 02:04 PM
Thread Name: BS: Mudcat Anti-semitism
Subject: RE: BS: Mudcat Anti-semitism
OK let's take a look at Little Hawk's "Ed", who he is now trying like hell to spin to win back his own populist standing within this forum, after having got it completely wrong by introducing "Ed".

Little Hawk - "I think the term "anti-semitism" has been overused, and used in an irresponsible way in recent historical times"

Perhaps LH you should have given some concrete and verifiable examples. Maybe a brief reprise of the actual holocaust followed by some quotes from the leaders of the nations neighbouring the State of Israel emphasising their desire to eliminate Israel, exterminate it and drive it's citizens into sea. Such sources are plentiful and are clearly documented, so no problem for you there Little Hawk.

So exactly where in your analogy is "Ed's" paranoia explained away as - "This may be because his family had a tough time in the past or it may be for some other reasons." Precisely when did you join the ranks of those denying that the holocaust ever happened - "This MAY BE because" - No fucking maybe about it Little Hawk - It damn well happened it happened because all those Germans in their lovely uniforms, tanks and aircraft that you so admire let it happen, participated in ensuring that it happened, and did everything in their power to ensure that the erradication was as complete as it could possibly be. Please do not come out with analogies based on " MAY BE BECAUSE" - Beause that simply denies history as everybody on this planet knows it. If there is any nation on this Earth who rightfully should be apprehensive with regard to threats of annihilation it is the Jews, don't dare try to trivialise that, it is a factor that should clearly be taken into account.

As for the salvage attempt of your rather pathetic analogy:-

Those - "generations of young Palestinians and other Muslims" - Exactly who the hell has ever voiced the desire to "wipe them from the map", who the hell has ever voiced the desire to, "Drive them into the sea", who the hell has ever voiced the aim of exterminating their entire race - NO ONE - FACT. Do not make patronising comparisons where none exist, you should have a greater regard for the intelligence of those who read and contribute to this forum.