I used to admire her work, Wolfgang. But since making the statement you quoted, I have learned a lot more about her. I no longer respect either her or her work.


Over-interpreting Manji's words as a blanket condemnation of "all" Muslims is absurd considering that she, herself, is a practicing Muslim.

And yet, had the same statement been made using the word "Jew" instead of "Muslim", many of the people on this thread as well as quite a few others not on this thread so far would have labeled it an anti-Semitic statement, or at least an incitement to hatred, regardless of whether or not it was said by a practicing Jew.