I too have mixed feelings. An argument could be made in favour of it such as this,that it gives children a focus, something to aim for. and is a better focus than competitions. Competitions can be discouraging for those who dont win, and are generally very subjective. So exams work in classical music, so why not other forms of music.Thirdly the question has to be asked why is the tradition in Ireland stronger than England is it because of the competion and exam system.Personally I feel the exam system is much better than the competion system, The benefits might be that children acquire more knowledge of english traditional music. Iam undecided. Finally to Anglo and his negative comments, if he/ she has nothingmore constructive to say, these comments pretty much sum up anglo him/ her self.I am busy enough doing two gigs a week. plus spending over two hours practice a day, if I wish to raise what I consider might be an important way of encouraging children to discover english traditional music I am going to, and Anglo can sling his hook.