The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #86416   Message #1832380
Posted By: Old Guy
12-Sep-06 - 01:16 AM
Thread Name: BS: KatrinaGate
Subject: RE: BS: KatrinaGate...
That NC Cabin gig sounds like fun.

New York Times:

Democrats were among the original and leading proponents of a cabinet-level DHS


http://frum.nationalreview.com/post/?q=NjYxZjI3N2Q1NTc3MWU1Yjk0MjZiZjc1ZWY5MWRjMjI=

After 9/11, Democrats demanded that the federal government take over airport security. I'm sure their motives were wholly public-spirited, but it may not have escaped their attention that federalizing airport security would expand the ranks of their supporters in the public-sector unions.
Republicans objected, but the Dems prevailed. To prevail, though, the Democrats had to rebut the GOP's best argument: the fear that civil service rules would prevent the government from ever firing an inept screener. No problem!-said the Dems at the time. Obviously people in vital front-line positions like homeland security have to be subject to strict discipline.

Six months later, the Dems proposed the creation of a vast new Homeland Security department. Many Republicans doubted the wisdom of regrouping departments rather than reforming them. Surely it matters less whether the Coast Guard reports to the Secretary of the Treasury or the Secretary of Homeland Security than whether it is fit and ready for its new role?

But Democrats insisted. The policy case for the new department might be weak, but the political case was overwhelming. The Democrats might be divided over military action in Iraq and a crackdown on terrorist support groups here at home, but they can always unite on the need for another gigantic bureaucracy.

And again, the Republicans gave way