You may have missed the following editing comment - as it was inserted into an existing post and did not refresh this thread.

Note: non-music birthday and obituary threads are routinely moved into the non-music section. If it's a thread about a musician that ends up being just congratulations and condolences without music information, it will also eventually get moved. But you knew that already. It has been said many times before.
Yes, it is a matter of judgment and it's not always a clear-cut matter. But that's what we get paid the big bucks for.
-Joe Offer-

Perhaps - as it is not clear-cut - our forum can be left to decide a threads fate? If it is of interest - it will be posted to - if it is not - it will fall off the page.