The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #94165   Message #1846885
Posted By: Old Guy
30-Sep-06 - 11:45 AM
Thread Name: BS: Has Walmart been defeated?
Subject: RE: BS: Has Walmart been defeated?
Attention RD:

Ad hominem as logical fallacy

A (fallacious) ad hominem argument has the basic form:

   1. A makes claim X.
   2. There is something objectionable about A.
   3. Therefore claim X is false.

The first statement is called a 'factual claim' and is the pivot point of much debate. The last statement is referred to as an 'inferential claim' and represents the reasoning process. There are two types of inferential claim, explicit and implicit.

Ad hominem is one of the best-known of the logical fallacies usually enumerated in introductory logic and critical thinking textbooks. Both the fallacy itself, and accusations of having committed it, are often brandished in actual discourse (see also Argument from fallacy). As a technique of rhetoric, it is powerful and used often, despite its inherent incorrectness.