Very astute observations, Jim, on learning songs. That is certainly the approach I have tried to take since I first delved onto the world of traditional song. Upon acquiring a new collection, whether in print or recorded, the first thing I do, after skimming the contents, is to sit back and read the notes so as to have a better understanding of the songs.

Since most of us who are singers did not grow up in the midst of a specific musical tradition, it is essential to both learn the song and learn about the song so as to be able to share that background when performing.

Please continue sharing your thoughts and experience with the rest of us, and maybe consider bcoming a member so as to allow for PMs -- Tom Hall