The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #99393   Message #1981365
Posted By: Don Firth
27-Feb-07 - 09:22 PM
Thread Name: Folk music lacking?
Subject: RE: Folk music lacking?
"Greensleeves is actually in the dorian mode, not a minor key. (No offense.)"

Well, it depends on which version. I've seen it written as strictly Dorian mode, and I've also seen it written as melodic minor. And I've seen mixed versions that start out Dorian and then go into melodic minor (most people tend to sing it that way). So which is the "authoritative" version? I prefer the Dorian, myself, but had I said "Dorian," I'm sure someone would have said, "No, it's in melodic minor."

Ya can't win.

Don Firth