Also, for what it's worth, two other tunes attributed to Carolan which he may not have written are Planxty George Brabazon (Twa Bonnie Maidens) and Sheebeg Sheemore (The Bonnie Cuckoo). I don't know if anyone will ever know for sure. In regards to being sacreligious and music - whoops, there goes the folk process.

Sandy, I once decided to act out the drooping maiden verse. (Swooning with back of hand to forehead, sliding down a wall.) Boy, did I get some dirty looks...