Oh well - just listened to the Corries' version, which seems to be most people's favourite. Sorry Jim, but I'm still not enamored with it and it's the tempo (especially on the chorus)rather than the melody. It's just too simple a 3/4 rhythm for my taste. But, as I said earlier, everyone likes it so who am I to deny the public what they want? I'll certainly continue to sing and play it when the venue calls for it.