The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #100629 Message #2023484
Posted By: Greg B
12-Apr-07 - 04:00 PM
Thread Name: BS: Don Imus replacment
Subject: RE: BS: Don Imus replacment
"Recently I was reading Stan Hugill's brilliant collection, and there were some dated references that would be considered racist by todays standard."
A couple of folks here have had US Government employees try to tell us not to sing certain politically incorrect songs (no, not with the n-word) from that collection. I believe we replied with their oath of service (something about uphold and protect the Constitution), followed by the 1st Amendment and refused to even HAVE that conversation.
But Mr. Hahn, and dianvan, and others keep driving right over the salient point without ever noting it--- if we're to get in the business either of government censorship or de facto public censorship of public commentators, 'legitimate' or not, we run into the problem of who's to be the arbiter of who is 'legitimate.'
If someone says 'cut off the funds, bring the troops home by date certain' someone else will say 'That's aiding and comforting the enemy, that's treason, he's just like Hanoi Jane, fire him.' Someone else claims that the WTC attackers may have had a legitimate underlying beef--- fire him too. Get out of the mainstream, and you get fired or fined.
I don't care for Imus, either. I find him tiresome and boring. He is, none the less, a legitimate social commentator--- some would even say a 'journalist'--- and to start demanding his censure or firing is to embark on the slippery slope where they may just come for YOU or your favorite commentator next. 'Are you now or were you ever a member of...' How quickly we forget.
It leaves me cold to think of the FCC doing it. Ever since Janet Jackson's boob fell out, the local radio station has to play the censored version of the Who's 'Who Are You.' And one of the local DJ teams, who always ended with Eric Idle singing 'Always Look on the Bright Side' now has a version where Eric sings '...life's a piece of isht, when ya look at it...' That kind of crap stopped for a few years. All because of Janet Jackson's tit, it's back. I'd hate to think of political commentators being subject to similar winds of whim.