exactly TIM,Here is an example that completely contradicts Jim Carrolls implication that all traditional singers would have a certain attitude to their songs.,[or perhaps Walters alleged attitude
The Broomfield Wager sung by Cyril Poacher on the BBC Recording, the singer and audience constantly interject the phrase Hold The Wheel,this arose as aresult of the singer trying to explain the story to a visiting yachtsman who misunsderstood had her will ,for hold the wheel.So the audience and singer were having a bit of FUN/CRAIC,not much different from the popping of the cheeks.
which might indicate ,that not all traditional singers had the same attitude to their material.
singers are singers whatever their label,some can cope with audience participation some cant.Fred Jordan IMO a consummate performer,Knew exactly how to play an audience,clearly Cyril Poacher when in the company of his mates didnt mind alittle bit of fun.
Brian Peters,while you should take what Jim Carroll says seriously,it is as well to remember it is only one take on the subject,John Howsons/SamRichards experiences ,may or may not confirm,or may differ,it is amistake to treat one persons information as gospel.