I should have said "You may feel smug that **THINK** you have caught someone in careless logic, "


"If one ignores the logical consequences of one's argument, how can one arrive at a logical solution?"

as I indicate, or tried to, I disagree that you have shown that they are, indeed, consequences....and IF they 'might' be, they are irrelevant to this discussion.


(Ok, Nickhere...we do have different basic premises working, but as Mick says, it was an enlightening exchance.)