The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #77963 Message #2145399
Posted By: Colin Randall
10-Sep-07 - 09:33 AM
Thread Name: Not-So-Good Lines in Songs
Subject: RE: Not-So-Good Lines in Songs
Pop not folk, but I have always thought these - from Elton john's Candle in the Wind, lyrics by Bernie Taupin - were among the worst lines ever written, if only because they are so sloppy
Even when you died The press still hounded you All the papers had to say Was that Marilyn was found in the nude
It is sloppy because of one word: WAS
If Taupin had written:
Even when you died/The press still hounded you/All the papers had to say/That Marilyn was found in the nude
...he would have been making the point he intended, ie that the evil press gleefully added that the body was naked. Instead, he suggests – absurdly of course – that the papers said ONLY that she was found in the nude. The reports of MM's death would, in those circumstances, have been very short indeed.