The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #97070   Message #2193551
Posted By: GUEST,leeneia
14-Nov-07 - 11:03 AM
Thread Name: Origin: Carnal and the Crane (from Maddy Prior)
Subject: RE: Origin: Carnal and the Crane (from Maddy Prior)
The page Jon linked (thanks, Jon) has a difficult time with the word 'carnal,' saying, 'The word would presumably be a borrowing from the French corneille.'

I suspect it's simply a dialect form for 'cardinal,' another kind of bird. I think it would be easy for people who do not read or write to lose track of the 'd' in the middle of 'cardinal.'

Of course,it would have been simpler if the person who collected the song had asked what it meant and kept a record!