The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #106771   Message #2275374
Posted By: CarolC
28-Feb-08 - 10:37 PM
Thread Name: BS: WMDs, Iran and Bush
Subject: RE: BS: WMDs, Iran and Bush
They don't allow for the Israelis to live peacefully in any place. They make it difficult and sometimes impossible for Jews to remain living.

This is bullshit. I've already shown you (and the fact of their existence is not subjective and can be proven) that there are Jews living in Palestinian villages with Palestinians. The reason they are accepted there is because they aren't living there as occupiers. Any Jews could live anywhere at all in both Israel and Palestine in peace if they would simply remove their jackboots off the necks of the non-Jewish indigenous people. If you've got your boot on my neck, I'm going to do everything I can to try to persuade you to remove it. This includes causing you to experience pain. I expect that the Palestinians feel the same way.

When the Palestinians cease to commit acfts of war against Israel, they will have peace. Until then, they will receive, for their attacks on Israeli and Arab civilians, TARGETED attacks on those who are attacking Israel, and on those who are supporting them.

They have a right to fight for their freedom from occupation. When the occupation ends, there will be peace. You cannot expect peace when you are brutally enslaving an entire people, and ethnically cleansing them from their place of origin.

The Palestinans have stated their goal is the elimination of Israel aned the Jews.

They have NEVER stated that they wish to eliminate "the Jews". Some Palestinians (hardly all of them) have stated the desire to remove the European colonialist Jews from their country. But, first of all, you cannot hold all Palestinians responsible for what some Palestinians have said, and secondly, many, many Jews have said that they want all Arabs removed from Israel and Palestine. If you can hold all Palestinians responsible for what some of them have said, that means we can hold all Jews responsible for what some Jews have said. Is that really what you want?

You have a very racist view of Arabs and Palestinians, beardedbruce. You treat them like they are some kind of hive collective rather than individual human beings. If I were to do the same thing in reference to Jews, I would be called and anti-Semite, and quite rightly so.