The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #106771   Message #2281140
Posted By: beardedbruce
06-Mar-08 - 09:16 AM
Thread Name: BS: WMDs, Iran and Bush
Subject: RE: BS: WMDs, Iran and Bush
There are still Muslim Israelis in Israel, CarolC. They suffer just as much under the attacks of Hamas as the Jewish Israelis do. I don't know the particular story of your neighbors, but Muslims and Christians (and Jews) are successfully living together in Israel NOW and since the 1880s.



"Maybe it was the Jewish paramilitaries who drove your neighbors off, but they were afraid to tell you that because they were afraid of possible repercussions if they did so."

Gee, they left Ramallah ( ON THE WEST BANK) between 1948 and 1960- WHEN IT WAS UNDER JORDANIAN CONTROL. You have a very convoluted idea of where and when "Jewish paramilitaries" were active.




"Currently, no land in Israel may be purchased from a Jew by anyone other than another Jew."

Care to provide any information on this? I have never heard of this, other than from sites that also claim the Holocaust never happened and Jews control the world.



"Do you support allowing non-Jews to purchase property from Jews in Israel?"

As much as YOU support Jews buying property from anyone in ANY Arab nation- You know maybe the property that was taken from them when they ( the Jews)+ were forced out in 1948- 1956?


"since they have NEVER stated ANY intent to kill ALL the Jews."

FALSE- YOU have never bothered to read the CHARTERS of Hamas, the other Palestinian organizations, the declarations of the Arab League in 1947 onward, the statements by the offiucial representatives of those groups, or the classroom materials preseted in UN sponsered Palestinian schools. YOU are the one making the blood libels.



"This is bullshit, beardedbruce, since you have not personally interviewed all of the Palestinians to know whether or not they have ever made such a claim."

I only have the emnity with those who HAVE made that statement- which includes the official representatives of many of the various Palestinian groups, the Arab League,etc. I have no emnity at all for Jordanians, Egyptians, or others that have NOT expressed the desire to kill Jews.

" You hate all Palestinians (and all Arabs, and all Muslims) and you are just making up this libel against them so you can justify your racist hatred. "

Another false statement, certainly a libel against me. YOU have never interviewed ALL Israelis, yet you make claims as to what they want to do, and why.

Why is that? If ONE peaceful Palestinian requires Jews to sit back and be killed without action, why is it that one peaceful Jew does not require that the Palestinians stop their mass bombardment attacks upon the civilian population ( Jews, Muslim, and Christian) of Israel?




I have stated there are Palestinians I do not hate- YOUR STATEMENT that I hate ALL Palestinians is a baltent lie, and obviously you have no desire to even deal with the truth.

I will regard your subsequent comments accordingly.