The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #109664   Message #2294442
Posted By: GUEST,Guest
21-Mar-08 - 10:51 AM
Thread Name: BS: Tavis Smiley on Wrightgate
Subject: BS: Tavis Smiley on Wrightgate
Guest and all others: Please observe the Copy and Paste suggestions in the FAQ. The political threads are especially bad right now. A tiny snip and your personal comments with the link only please.

As the snow falls this morning, and I am not ensared in my daily commute, I've had some time to play catch w/my reading on the campaign, and the fallout from Obama's speech.

I don't know how many, if any of you, watch Tavis Smiley. I like his show a lot (when I can keep my eyes open that late), and often watch it online (because I can't keep my eyes open that late).

He has done quite a bit of really good work on this election, including coverage of Obama that has been judicious and fair. So I was drawn to read some statements he made about The Speech.

FROM THE SOUTH FLORIDA TIMES:

Smiley takes on Obama at Florida Memorial

BY JOY-ANN REID   

Talk show host and political commentator Tavis Smiley dove headlong into the controversy over Barack Obama's former pastor, the Rev. Jeremiah Wright, as he headlined Florida Memorial University's Second Annual Presidential Scholarship Banquet last weekend.

Smiley addressed the controversy over his frequent criticism of Obama's presidential campaign, calling Obama "a friend of mine,'' but admonishing "all the Obama supporters in the room'' that voting for the candidate won't wipe the historical slate clean between black and white America, "just as voting for Hillary won't do away with the legacy of sexism in America."

Smiley chided Obama for his recent condemnation of Wright, the recently retired pastor of Trinity United Church of Christ in Chicago, over sermons that were recently distributed over the Internet, including one
in which Wright tied the 9/11 terror attacks to the U.S. bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, and U.S. policy in the Middle East and South Africa.

Smiley said he was distressed by what he called Obama "throwing Wright under the bus'' adding that many of Wright's criticisms of U.S. policy have been echoed in the work of black intellectuals, including Harvard University law professor Charles Ogletree, Pulitzer Prize winning author Toni Morrison, and his friend and mentor, Cornel West, whom Smiley said wrote in his book, Democracy Matters about America's "chickens coming home to roost'' on 9/11.

The March 15 event commemorated the university's 40th anniversary in South Florida. The school, founded in 1879 in St. Augustine, moved to Miami Gardens in 1968.

Addressing the Obama issue

Smiley seemed to address Obama over the Rev. Jeremiah Wright controversy as he told the sometimes apprehensive crowd, "If you're gonna condemn the remarks every time someone shows you a transcript, you're gonna be throwing Negroes under the bus every week." And he added, "we ain't got to demonize 'us' to prove our loyalty to 'them.'"

Smiley, who has been sharply criticized by some African-Americans for his lack of support for a man many consider to be the most credible black candidate for president to date, said he has received threats following caustic commentaries about Obama on "The Tom Joyner Morning Show."

Yet he pulled no punches in taking on the Illinois Senator, turning his keynote speech into a vigorous defense of Rev. Wright, and of African-American patriotism.

"The thing about the Jeremiah Wright situation that's so troubling to me is that you can't let other folk define the terms. Some folk have learned to love this country 'because of …' most of us in this room have learned to love this country 'in spite of,' and we're still patriots. So I'm not gonna let Sean Hannity, or John McCain, or anybody else define for me what patriotism is. You've got to love your country enough to tell the truth."

Smiley even took a page from Obama's campaign, saying black America has historically been "living in a place called hope" – hoping to live in a country "as good as its promise," even though evidence that the country has lived up to its promise failed to materialize.

He told the assembled students, faculty and supporters, that to be "free," they had to be prepared to tell the truth.

Of Obama, he asked, "if you're asking for black folks' support, do you love us? Will you tell the truth about our suffering?"

Smiley praised the university's work in helping to educate a new generation of leaders. And he closed his remarks quoting both King and West, choosing the King quote: "Cowardice asks the question: 'Is it safe?' Expediency asks the question: 'is it politic?' Vanity asks the question: 'Is it popular?' But conscience asks the question: 'Is it right'," saying, "there comes a time when one must take a position that is neither safe, nor politic, nor popular, but one must take it because one's conscience tells one what is right."