Having just visited this site for the first time I am interested in the debate on origin of "Sean South of Garryowen" and the claim of 5th December 2002 that this may in someway be connected to Cathal Ó Sándair seems to be adequately challenged. I knew Cathal ó Sándair well and proud to say I am his eldest son so why wouldn't I ? Cathal was indeed a wonderful father and very gifted writer though I doubt if he would even claim the remotest credit for a connection with this song. I believe I am aware of most or all of my late father's writing endeavours - if anyone has any further "pearls of wisdom" to offer me about my Dad or his writings I would be happy to hear ! Terence Saunders (Moscow)