The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #114038   Message #2431781
Posted By: WFDU - Ron Olesko
05-Sep-08 - 09:53 AM
Thread Name: Tech: Why do we need Recording Studios?
Subject: RE: Tech: Why do we need Recording Studios?
"good enough for Folk"

The words "good" and "enough" should never be used in the same sentence.

I'm sorry Jim, but that statement is one of the reasons why "folk music" has such a reputation among the masses.   While we may appreciate the "do it yourself" and "home made" quality, the rules change as soon as you step in front of a microphone or perform for an audience.

Folk music SHOULD be made in homes, schools, churches, work, etc. The soul of this music is meant to encourage participation, not exhibition.   Over time, perhaps putting the blame on the "folk revival", the music ALSO found a home on the stage.   

Too often, people decide for themselves that their music deserves to be heard by others - whether others want to hear it or not. I'm sure all of us have sat through "performances" by people who sing off-key with instruments out of tune and singing songs that have little connection or feeling.   In their own mind, they are the next Pete Seeger. To the audience that sits through the performance, that singer becomes the image of "folk music" and the reason why they won't return.

Jim, I listened to your samples - and you are very good. The recordings, coming off a compressed MP3 through a crappy computer speaker still sounds promising.   However, what works for you is not necessarily going to work for others.

You also said "The software is designed for the novice and most Studio Software suppliers offer all sorts of support.
For the first time in history, the playing field is actually tilted in favour of the independent artist"    I have to strongly disagree.

You can buy software at your local Staples, but it is NOT the same softward that is used in reputable studios. Sure, you will get a fairly good sound, but you are not going to replicate the powerful software unless you spend the big bucks.

It is because of this software and cheap equipment that independent artists struggle. The cream does not always rise to the top because they are mired in a sea of mediocre.   You can give a painter a cheap brush that is missing bristles and paint that is difficult to spread, and while they might create something interesting - they are not going to work to their full potential because of limitations placed on them.

Your creativity might be sapped in a studio, but for others their creativity begins to flow once they realize the potential.