The Mudcat Café TM
Thread #114653 Message #2449298
Posted By: Art Thieme
24-Sep-08 - 06:54 PM
Thread Name: Traditional singers altering songs?
Subject: RE: Traditional singers altering songs?
Old cowboy Del Bray (possibly Dave Bray) surely did sing:
Near Medicine Bow where I was born, There was a fair maid dwellin', Made all the boys ride saddle sore, And her name was Barbara Allen...
Did he put it together. I have no idea.
We were in a bar in Cheyenne, Wyoming -- the summer of 1962. He saw my guitar case and we went across the street to a rather rundown hotel room we had taken for the night. (This was across from the train station as I remember it.) I was 20 years old, underage, but we bought a 6-pack and shared it back in the room. Then we swapped some songs. I asked Del if he knew any cowboy songs. He took my guitar and sang what I called "Cowboy's Barbara Allen." He sang it one time and I wrote down what I had heard. Quite some time later, I re-discovered that paper in my case---and I fleshed it out fom versions I knew before. Where this western version differed from the usual renditions, I had written these glaring differences down, but not the surrounding words.
The song wound up being at least 75% Del Bray, but I admit it had to be finished by me.
The song is in the DT. Recently, Joel Mabus, an old friend, recorded the song. Quite a few words were different from the way I generally did it. The verses about "Do you remember in yonder town... You gave a toast to all the girls, but slighted Barbara Allen." Those verses were NOT in Del Bray's singing of it---so they are not in my version.
...and the "thorny briar" and the "rose" mingling on top of the grave's "marker rocks" --- This was because, on the plains of the American west, rocks were often piled on the graves to keep wolves from digging up the dead.