Sorry Barry, but it looks like we just have to accept that we disagree on this topic.   I have high respect for your opinion, and I do not doubt that you found the sessions "boring" as you described. I still wonder what the rest of the attendees felt - if these sessions have been going on for awhile, someone must enjoy them.   As for the session that you like, it seems like a wonderful event, but if someone is going to feel ostracized if they bring in a book, then I would have to classify it as "elite".   Again, that is not meant as a putdown. If you have something good, you are certainly entitled to keep it going. You say that outsiders are welcome, but I have to wonder if others feel the same way.   You do make it sound intimidating.

Again, I meant no disrespect to anyone who has shared their thoughts.   My personal opinion is that a song circle is about the joy of singing, and I think everyone needs to approach it with an understanding of all the participants and do whatever they can to encourage others to join in.   If you feel you have the right formula, good luck to you. I assume that I won't be hearing any future discussions about why folk music is dieing and why people aren't turning out for sessions.   I assume whatever solutions are out there are meant to be inclusive and welcoming to younger generations.

Sing for the song, not the performance.