Barry, from what I am seeing - the "neighborhood" IS in danger of dieing. Change for the better is needed, at least in this neck of the woods and other parts of the country from what I am gathering in these threads. I respect your opinion of the sessions that you enjoy, but I'm not convinced that "very few" are enjoying sessions where books are used.    Earlier you used an analogy about Chinese restaurants and where to find the best food - well, there is also a reason why the neighborhood restaurant is still in business and there are probably people who enjoy it.   Your tastes may differ, but there are people who find great comfort in the "book". More power to them.

As Nelson said, there is no "right" or "wrong" - whatever works for your area and community.