Well, I don't know how the figures in 1948 compare with the figures at various earlier dates - maybe they are higher, maybe they are lower. I think it'd be quite complicated to get those figures for the West Bank as such. If someone can get them together, fine.

But the actual figures aren't actually the issue. The issue is the right of exiles to return home, and that is something that shouldn't be qualified by whether they are Jews or Christians or Moslems or none of the above.