I went and paid iTunes $0.99 for a copy of Sam Hinton's version. The words aren't the same as the above, as it really starts with "Whoever shall have some good peanuts". I guess I will edit-up the above and post it here.

I typed Good Peanuts in the search box, yesterday and today, and it didn't find anything -- yet I see it is there from the link above. Why doesn't the search here work? I didn't find it in Google, either.

It also shows a picture of a CD by Sam Hinton, also called "Whoever Shall Have Some Good Peanuts", so it isn't that rare. I don't know if that was the record I had or not.