Well, I just saw the story, and I'd give it five stars. My stepson worried about the inconsistencies, but I just enjoyed the movie.

I told him it's like the Bible, which (to my mind) is full of inconsistencies. Some people reject the Bible as fraudulent because it isn't absolutely consistent. Some dance around in circles trying to rationalize the inconsistencies and prove it's all true. I dont think either perspective is worthwhile.

With Star Trek, why not just watch the movie and enjoy it, and learn the lessons it has to teach us?

-Joe-