"Why do you need to turn pleasure at this development into a character flaw of anyone who professes to enjoy her voice and understand her story?"

I haven't said one word about anyones character.

I've said that I think Susan Boyle is overrated and that she owes her fame to cynical hype.

I've also wished her well and good luck in the competition.

Do I see the performers as corrupt?

Well what did I say - That I know her as well as anyone else here ie not at all.

So I haven't made any cooment on her character except that I don't know anymore about it than anyone else here.


As for the audience on the clip ...

... watch it again honestly and tell me that that is an honest audience response ...

She's a nice singer.

She isn't any more than that.

The rest is fluff.