"what it comes down to is that you don't particularly enjoy her singing and I do"

Actually I haven't said whether I like her or not - I've said I don't think she stands out from other singers.

And I've given my reasons.

But as Alan says, I'm repeating myself ...

... I did try to get on track with the Porgy and Bess comments.


I hope they don't give her the whole "rock orchestra" treatment with cheesy drumming and big exaggerated key changes as you would expect from Celine Dion etc ...

... I sadly suspect that that is what you can expect her managers, with a little guidance from the cowell morgan mafia, to prescribe for her roadshow repertoire.

You'll be able to catch her live don't forget when the BGT tour happens.